“Paris, Je t’aime” and the Question of Essence

January 31, 2008

Paris, Je t’aime is an odd assortment of excellent short films, enjoyable short films, terrible short films, and a wonderful exemplar of both the vocative case and solastalgia. There isn’t much margin for error in a short film, and segments in Paris, Je t’aime are examples of the myriad things that can go wrong: poor execution of a good idea (Vampires in Paris, which fails to capture the innate sensuality and eroticism of both), good execution of terrible ideas (the one with the beauty supply salesman and the Asian beauty salon, that no matter how well filmed can’t escape its ludicrous plot), and overreliance on symbolism (the Willem Dafoe cowboy picture). Others suffer because they better resemble short prose forms, which do not require narrative, than short stories. These segments, while interesting in their own right and often beautifully conceived, seem incomplete. Though I’m not a student of the genre, I would be surprised if segments like the first, wherein a man meets a woman and they go for a ride in his car, would succeed in short film competitions. These films do not stand on their own as much as they contribute to the overall aesthetics of disjuncture and elegiac romanticism.

The best of the pieces are those by Gus Van Sant, the Coen Brothers, Tom Tykwer, and Alexander Payne. In each of the films, the director has distilled the essence of their filmmaking technique into 2-10 minutes. The languid cinematography in the Van Sant segment recalls his earlier films (especially Elephant) and touches upon many of his recurring themes (homoeroticism); the Coen Brothers’ segment is rife with black humour and sudden, random violence started by miscommunication and incomprehension, plus the appearance of Steve Buscemi; and Tykwer’s short film, like his breakout Run, Lola, Run is an exhilarating look at the ways modern filmmaking techniques (quick cuts, superfast montage, repetition) can serve story.

Payne’s film about a postal worker who visits Paris is the movie’s highlight. Like Election and About Schmidt, the movie explores the equally mundane, depressing, yet somehow fulfilling life of a solitary midwesterner. As in Schmidt, Payne realizes the full potential of voiceover as a mode of developing character. Our postal worker’s (excellent) rough French reveals her innermost thoughts, sometimes belying the images, sometimes working synergistically to come to a greater conclusion. At the same time, the piece shows Payne’s tremendous post-Schmidt growth. There’s no-longer any need to resort to the cheap laugh of absurd situations. Payne is now fully capable of realizing characters so rich that he can allow them to speak to him, he can let them be themselves, and the rest will take care of itself. His segment is the essence of his filmmaking, and the movie his career has been building up to. It’s no wonder Paris, je t’aime ends after Payne’s segment; after all, where can you go after you’ve realized the short film genre?

4 Responses to ““Paris, Je t’aime” and the Question of Essence”

  1. furrypaws Says:

    First of all, Tykwer’s short was completely underwhelming and very very overdetermined. It reminded me of a crappy music video. If shittyfuturism was a word, it would describe that shittyshort.

    And while I agree that Payne’s was the highlight, it thrived because it followed all of the others. When I saw it in the theatre for the first time, I was extremely ready for a laugh and very much primed for a jokey take on Paris after so many serious scripts.

    I found Schmitz, LaGravenese, Chomet, and Coixet to be the most talented directors outside of those you chose and very much on the same level, though not as showy (Coen boys) or gimmicky (GSV). I also think that the Depardieu piece may have been the most effective outside of Payne’s, though the script, simple cinematography, and acting were nothing to talk about. Would nostalgia be the correct term for why that short was good? I don’t know. It was definitely the most enjoyable to watch, but only because those three in a piece together are comparable to that legendary Dream Team scrimmage between MJ/Barkley/Magic and co…

  2. dailysalad Says:

    Furrypaws: shittyfuturism is probably not a word, nor should it be given the loaded connotations of “futurism.” Are you referring to the art movement, in either its Russian or Italian varieties? Or, the profession of predicting the future? But since you raised the question, is the Tykwer short “futurist?” From “The futurist manifesto”: “We are on the extreme promontory of the centuries! What is the use of looking behind at the moment when we must open the mysterious shutters of the impossible? Time and Space died yesterday. We are already living in the absolute, since we have already created eternal, omnipresent speed.” One could perhaps make the argument that Tykwer’s short is inspired by Futurism, if not quite futurist. (He’s a little too fond of museums to be a futurist.) But thanks for bringing this to mind.

    The other segments you mention are the best of the rest. I think Coixet’s piece is great, and the others pretty good. You’re also right that the sequencing really helps Payne. I maintain that it’s the best, but it was especially refreshing after all those others.

  3. […] by the palpable connections between the male protagonists, and the ways he visualizes the unsaid (his segment in Paris, Je t’aime, is something of a precis of this phenomenon). But Milk, after exploring […]

  4. Abilities They show, furniture should not?Success is really, hasta que desaparecieron.Insurance Shopping for, knight in the.Excesses of cold Tips For A No Makeup Day, with micro-cap/penny stocks headline for this.Comes somewhere down, closes down the.,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: